12 New Mouth-Watering Sandwich Maker Recipes

Panini Press. Sandwich Maker. Toastie Maker. It has its variations, and some are different from others, but one thing remains – A hot, satisfying snack in your hands every time.

If you’re getting bored with the sandwich maker ideas you have… then you’ll love this. I’ve compiled a list of 12 delicious recipes for sandwich maker (and other tasty treats) that will revamp your lunch today.

WARNING: You may find you won’t be able to make it through the whole list without your mouth watering.

12 New Mouth-Watering Sandwich Maker Recipes In 2019

If you’re ready to take your lunch to the next level, and really up your sandwich maker game, then this list of sandwich maker recipes is the most important thing you’ll read today.

If you find yourself in a little mess after your masterpiece is complete, we also have a guide on how to clean your sandwich maker in 4 easy steps, so we have you covered there too! Happy cooking!

P.S. If you’re wondering what else you can make besides toasties, I won’t judge so this list includes a few secret gems that will surprise you and I am sure you will find your recipe for sandwich maker that you have been wanting spice up your choice.

1. Eggplant, (Skinny) Pesto & Mozzarella Panini

Your love of the hot, tasty sandwich toaster recipe brought you here. Though there are several alternative treats on this list, I need to start off right… with an incredible snack.

This Eggplant, (Skinny) Pesto, & Mozzarella Panini from SkinnyTaste is one of the most popular to make on the sandwiches machine.  It is light, crispy, and like a little trip to Italy in your hands.

2. Cheesy Pepperoni Pizza Panini

Making the decision between a nice, crispy toastie and a big cheesy slice of pizza is often a very difficult task. So… the folks at The Recipe Critic made an important discovery: You can combine the two to make something beautiful, so I could not leave this sandwich toaster recipe out.

This cheesy pepperoni pizza panini is oozing with flavor and of course, cheese! If you’re vegetarian, you can substitute the pepperoni for peppers or olives.

3. Gooey Brownies

If you have ever wondered whether there are any sandwich maker dessert recipes, the answer is OH YES. Note: This recipe does require a “floating lid” style panini press instead of a regular swivel press.

But if you’re looking for a little bit of sweetness at home Not a problem!

Believe it or not, you can make gooey brownies with your panini press. Sounds crazy, doesn’t it? Check out the recipe at Panini Happy and see for yourself! Cook up a scrumptious lunch, then make these gooey brownies. Dinner & Dessert

4. Triangle “UFOs”

Note: This recipe only works for a design with triangle well plates. If you liked the pizza recipe, but want something a bit more filling, then this is the recipe for you.

Pocket sandwich maker recipes are another brilliant idea to brighten up your lunch this Tasty Island Hawaii is quick and easy. You just put together bread with a hearty spaghetti sauce to make a pocket sandwich ready to eat! Yum!

5. Brie, Ham & Apple Quesadilla

If you’re wanting something a little lighter that’s packed with a ton of flavor, then check out this unique recipe from All Day I Dream About Food.

It’s cheesy, it’s salty, it’s sweet. And it has a health-conscious alternative available so this definitely makes it onto my recipes for a sandwich maker ideas list.

6. Powdered Cakes

Note: This recipe only works for designs with triangle well plates. But when you want something sweet or if you’re looking for something a little lighter than the brownies, add this to your list of sandwich maker dessert recipes.

It’s an awesome little alternative to pancakes that are dangerously addictive! Fauzia’s Kitchen shows you exactly how to make these sweet, little, powdered treats.

7. Ice Cream Cones

Now, how about this to add to your repertoire of sandwich toaster recipes. Imagine you’re walking down the street. Something catches your nose. Waffles. Waffle cones? Yep. It’s an ice cream shop. The tantalizing aroma almost pulls you right in.

Now you can have the same thing, at home, with your press. Panini Happy’s ice cream cone recipe is a unique and tasty treat for you to test out.

8. Shredded Hash Browns

Still looking for more recipes using sandwich maker ideas? Then this is yet another that is just scrummy. Shredded hashbrowns, just because, why not, right? If you’re a breakfast lover, then feast your eyes on this.

It’s a perfect little secret hashbrown recipe from Good Cheap Eats.

9. Grilled Smashed Potatoes

As sandwich toaster recipes go this is one of my favorite little snacks (and one of the easiest as it doesn’t require many ingredients). Turn your potatoes into an extremely satisfying snack with this smashed potatoes recipe from Panini Happy.

Mmmm…

10. Grilled Salmon & Asparagus

If you’re wanting to get really healthy (and eat something delicious)… then you’ll love this recipe by Everyday Sandwich for grilled salmon and asparagus!

Impress your partner with this recipe. You’ll love the look in their eyes when you tell them you did it all on a panini press.

11. Frittata

Note: This recipe only works for designs with triangle well plates. You’ve seen the hashbrowns recipe. Now, leave that frying pan alone and whip up an omelet on your sandwich maker.

With the triangle wells, it creates a perfectly shaped omelet ready for breakfast. Thanks to Nigerian Food TV, you can see exactly how to make it!

12. Bacon Strips

First, the hashbrowns, then the omelet. Could we really leave you hanging… without your bacon?

Lucky for you, Panini Happy shows you how to make the perfectly crispy bacon strips to go right along with your gourmet breakfast.